Drew Patterson is an exceptional, multifaceted attorney. He continually strives to understand the intricacies of our business and produce results. He is highly recommended.
Can You Defame a Company?
January 20, 2025
Defamation can seriously harm a business by damaging its reputation, reducing customer trust, and leading to financial losses. False statements, whether written as libel or spoken as slander, that misrepresent a company’s actions, ethics, or economic standing may give rise to legal action. While opinions and fair criticism are protected by free speech laws, knowingly spreading false information can have legal consequences.
To succeed in a defamation claim, a business must prove that the statement was false, published to a third party, and caused measurable harm. False accusations of fraud, unethical behavior, or criminal conduct can be particularly damaging and may justify legal action. Companies that have suffered reputational harm should explore their options to protect their interests.
Legal Standards for Business Defamation
Businesses that file defamation claims must meet specific legal criteria:
False Statement
The statement must be verifiably false, as truthful claims—even if harmful—are not considered defamatory. A business cannot sue over negative but truthful feedback, but statements containing false accusations of fraud, misconduct, or illegal activities may qualify.
Publication
The false statement must have been communicated to a third party, meaning it was posted online, shared in a news article, or spoken publicly. Private conversations typically do not meet this requirement unless they cause measurable harm.
Negligence or Malice
If the business is a private entity, it must prove the statement was made negligently, meaning the speaker failed to verify the accuracy of their claims. If the business is a public company, it must meet a higher burden of proof by demonstrating “actual malice,” meaning the false statement was made intentionally or with reckless disregard for the truth.
Damages
The business must show actual harm, such as a decline in revenue, loss of clients, reputational damage, or other quantifiable financial consequences. A company that cannot prove tangible harm may struggle to establish a valid defamation claim.
Defamation cases require clear evidence and strategic legal action. The Law Offices of Robert Eckard & Associates, P.A. can evaluate whether a company has substantial grounds for a lawsuit and advise on the best action. Consulting with our Palm Harbor business lawyer can help businesses understand their legal options and take the necessary steps to protect their reputations.
Can Negative Reviews Be Defamatory?
Consumer reviews are generally protected as long as they reflect genuine experiences. However, false statements presented as fact—such as baseless claims of fraud, unethical business practices, or illegal activity—can be considered defamation. Legal action may be necessary when false reviews cause financial harm or damage to a company’s reputation.
Businesses dealing with defamatory reviews or false allegations should not ignore the consequences. Pursuing a claim through business litigation can help restore a company’s credibility and recover losses. A business litigation attorney in Tampa, FL, can take the necessary steps to hold those responsible accountable and protect the business’s long-term success.
Challenging Business Defamation Claims
Not every negative statement about a business is defamatory. Common defenses include:
- Truth – A true statement, even if damaging, is not defamation.
- Opinion – Subjective opinions that do not present false facts are protected under free speech laws.
- Lack of Harm – If a business cannot prove financial or reputational harm, the claim may not hold up in court.
Consulting with a Tampa business attorney is essential to determine the best legal strategy if your business faces defamation claims.
Defending Your Business Against Defamation Claims
False and damaging statements can have long-term effects on a company’s success. Businesses facing defamation should act quickly to mitigate harm and explore legal remedies. The Law Offices of Robert Eckard & Associates, P.A. provides strategic representation for companies in Florida and Texas, helping them address defamation issues effectively. Contact us today to discuss your legal options.